White Elephant Gift Ideas People Actually Fight Over (Under $25)
Cozy, useful, funny and food gifts under $25 that get stolen, not skipped. Plus what to leave at home.
Hintbook may earn a commission when you shop through these links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Every White Elephant has two kinds of gifts: the ones that get stolen three times and the ones that sit in a corner while everyone pretends to love them.
The good ones have something in common. They're useful, a little indulgent and something almost anyone would want. Here's what works, grouped by type, all for about $25 or less.
Cozy gifts (the most stolen category)
Photo: Costa Live on Unsplash
- A plush throw blanket. The classic winner. Pick a soft, neutral one.
- Heated or weighted something. A heated hand warmer, microwavable neck wrap or heated mug.
- Fuzzy slipper socks or slippers. Stick to one-size styles.
- A really good candle. Not a gas-station candle. A nice one in a clean scent like cedar or fig.
Food and drink
Photo: Rafael Pedroso on Unsplash
Everyone eats, so these are hard to get wrong.
- A snack box with fancy chips, popcorn, chocolate and something local.
- Hot chocolate bombs or a nice hot cocoa kit.
- Good olive oil + flaky salt. People rarely buy the nice versions for themselves.
- A coffee sampler from a local roaster.
- Mini bottles + mixers for a cocktail kit (adults-only parties, obviously).
Useful gadgets
Photo: Irina Chishkova on Unsplash
- A portable phone charger. Not exciting until yours dies.
- A mini waffle maker. Cheap, fun, gets stolen.
- Wireless earbuds case or a phone stand.
- An insulated tumbler that actually keeps things hot.
- A small Bluetooth speaker.
Fun and games
- A card game for adults. Games that are easy to learn and quick to play are best.
- A 500-piece puzzle with a great image.
- A desk toy or fidget for the office crowd.
Funny gifts that still land
Gag gifts are risky. The best ones are funny and useful, so the person who ends up with one doesn't just throw it away.
- A giant mug that holds a whole pot of coffee.
- A "World's Okayest" anything.
- A comically large wine glass that holds a full bottle.
- A ridiculous but cozy item like a blanket with sleeves or a heated scarf.
Gift cards (wrapped right)
Gift cards are great if they're wrapped well. Put a coffee shop card inside a mug with a bag of beans. Put a bookstore card inside a book. Put a pizza card in a pizza box with a note. Presentation makes them get stolen instead of skipped.
What to skip
- Clothes with sizes. Odds are it won't fit the person who ends up with it.
- Strong scents like perfume or heavy candles. Too personal.
- Things that are only funny for five seconds. Novelty items end up in the trash by New Year's.
- Anything that needs to match someone's decor.
- Regifts that look like regifts. Regifting is fine. Just make sure it's new and good.
A quick rule of thumb
Ask yourself: would I be a little excited if I ended up with this? If yes, bring it. If you'd secretly hope someone steals it from you, keep shopping.
New to the game? Here are the full White Elephant rules and variations.
FAQ
What's the most popular White Elephant gift?
Cozy blankets and good snacks get stolen the most. Useful, a little indulgent and good for almost anyone is the winning formula.
Are gift cards good White Elephant gifts?
Yes, especially to coffee shops or popular stores. Wrap them inside something so they don't look like an afterthought.
What should you not bring to White Elephant?
Skip anything too personal (clothes in a size), anything that needs a specific taste (strong perfume) and anything that's only funny for five seconds.